Real David H.

older. wiser. slower.

Thoughts on the New York City Marathon

Originally posted at 11:52 a.m.:
I feel like people are arguing with me on Twitter every time I post something about this weekend’s New York City Marathon. Let me take this opportunity beyond 140 characters to explain.

As someone who has worked in the media business, PR and now social media, I know what it’s like to get screamed at from both sides of an argument. I’ve met many irrational people over the years. I’ve also met a lot of people who are passionate. Whether or not I agree with them, I respect them.

I also learned after being at an NGO (non-governmental organization, similar to a nonprofit) that changed its name, that crisis communication is important.

A year ago, a freak snowstorm pounded the Northeast. The New York City Marathon cleaned things up and moved forward without delay. I am being perfectly honest when I say I have no idea what type of communication was being put forth prior to the event. I’m sure many people had questions.

That said, the storm was also an opportunity to answer the question: What do we do if that happens again? In a city that has seen terrorist attacks, major power outages (remember the Black Out?) and an October snowstorm in the past 11 years, an organization that hosts tens of thousands of people for an even should have crisis communication in place.

The New York Road Runners have proven over the past two days since Hurricane Sandy hit that they have no crisis communications in place. Some people have said they have sent emails – I’ve seen some of those emails. They’re the same that’s also being posted on their website and Facebook – 12+ hours apart. (The consistency in the messages is a good thing, actually. The time apart, not so much.)

You also have Mayor Bloomberg stating that it’s his “understanding” that the marathon will go on. That is not a definitive answer.

The current responses on their website and Facebook page (nothing on Twitter since an automated post Tuesday morning) are legally crafted words that have left people confused. Don’t take my word for it. See the comments on their Facebook page.

Whether or not the race should go on is something that many are debating. I won’t get into that too much. I’m not on the ground there to understand what it’s really like, although a friend of mine in the city told me that it felt “too soon.”

There’s also the moral argument. Should a race go on with food and water when people in the area have been forced out of their homes due to flood and fires? I’m not going to weigh in on that discussion either, but it’s a valid question.

What people want are simple responses. NYRR and ING NYC Marathon: Get a PR firm on board somewhere to manage your accounts. All of them. Right now. With some people’s various lines of communication being cut, the same messages need to go out via email, Facebook and Twitter.

Even if you honestly can’t say yes or no, you can say something.

3:16 p.m. Update, from the mayor’s office:

3:31 p.m. update, from Mary Wittenberg CEO of New York Road Runners:

NYRR, NYCM, twitter

19 responses to “Thoughts on the New York City Marathon”

  1. Dori Avatar

    YES. My friends who are running are totally understanding of the decision to cancel or not, but they are NOT understanding about the uncertainty and lack of communication. I work in social media as well and know what it’s like to be yelled at from all sides, and the best thing you can do is COMMUNICATE. Proactively! NYRR has had these general lack-of-communication issues before and I can’t believe they still haven’t improved on this.

    Like

    1. Fabs Avatar
      Fabs

      I m not the biggest fan of NYRR, but I believe they have issued a very clear statement on their website. As long as there are no news, there is nothing to report.

      Like

      1. David H. Avatar

        They should be offering suggestions on people who are trying to come into down over the next few days. I saw a post from an expo vendor on their Facebook page who hasn’t been told much.
        The statement on their website is not clear, and many others have noted that as well.

        Like

  2. Mark Matthews Avatar

    Great post. I’m flyiing in from Michigan, at least supposed to be. So many issues. I’m supposed to take water from an aid station when folks don’t all have running water ?(I presume) and be protected by city workers while they are needed elsewhere?. It feels wrong and different than the post 911 run. Of course, I could cancel if I felt strong enough, but it would be best if they just canceled, IMHO. It seems more runners feel this way than don’t that I have heard. As for PR, I get the same sense that you do, that they are being careful with the wording and there is uncertainty in the air. It seems every time there is the announcement ‘the race will go on’ it has a string attached saying ‘unless the guy behind me says otherwise’. I could totally deal with “There are no changes at this time, but a final decision will be made by such and such ‘exact’ time” but I haven’t heard this. This all may change in the next few hours. And as is usually the case with things like these, there is more going on behind the scenes than I realize.

    Like

  3. robertw Avatar
    robertw

    Good points and well stated. They will have the race. They are trying to determine if any changes need to be made and frankly they seem afraid to give out any information. Also there is limited food and water in the race. The race is not taking supplies that people need.. People are being overly dramatic. I live in South Fla and we had our share of hurricanes. Under that premise should restaurants open? People in NY have water. We are not using their water.

    Like

    1. David H. Avatar

      Sure it’s not “their” water, but how about the people who lived in the 50 homes that burned down? Do they have access to food and water? I don’t know answers to questions like that, but I think it’s a legitimate question a few days after the fact.

      Like

  4. j. Avatar

    As someone who is registered for the race, I wholeheartedly concur with this post. Cancel it, or don’t. I understand that there are bigger and more important things out there than the marathon. But people are coming from all over the world and we deserve a definitive decision. I have no doubt that NYRR and its employees are working so hard to make this happen. But if it’s not possible to do so, then shouldn’t we be told before we make the trip? The lack of communication is really terrible and it’s not fair to any of the 45k+ runners who have worked so hard to train for the race.

    Like

  5. Lora V Avatar
    Lora V

    David, you are claiming NYRR should say “something” and they have. I support NYRR at this moment in their choice to not disseminate empty information in favor of waiting until the situation’s been thoroughly assessed.
    Social media seems to foster an unrealistic expectation that information should be provided immediately. With something of this magnitude, I believe waiting until there is quality and factual information is more beneficial to the people involved.

    Criticizing NYRR’s social media practices in the moment of a city-wide catastrophe does nothing to help the situation.

    Like

    1. David H. Avatar

      I’m criticizing their overall communication. To put out a message via email, Facebook and Twitter at the same time takes no effort. This isn’t about social media — this is about the lack of crisis communications. What they have said, basically, is that every effort is being made to proceed with the race and that they’re “keeping their options open.” Communicating via the media and a loose statement from the mayor is not saying “something.”

      Like

  6. Michelle @ Running with Attitude Avatar

    Great post David – the lack of clear communication is really disappointing. My background is marketing and brand management and I have to say I’m left shaking my head at the lack of communications management. Hold or cancel it, but for everyone’s sake, make a decision!

    Like

    1. David H. Avatar

      Thank you Michelle.

      Like

  7. misszippy Avatar

    Great perspective. I am seeing passion on both sides of the argument, that is for sure. Some clarity from NYRR would certainly help.

    Like

  8. Patrick Avatar

    I work in communications and completely agree with your comments about crisis communications.

    Like

  9. Charlotte Avatar

    NYRR has turned into a big business. They feel so corporate to me. They will do anything for money, and if that means shutting up until they know for sure whether or not the show can go on.. they will.
    Just my opinion.
    Whether or not it SHOULD go on is an entirely different discussion; but they should at least say “hey we’re not sure” if they aren’t sure. SOMETHING.

    Like

  10. coco Avatar

    My guess is that they really don’t know yet what conditions will be like — even now after they’ve said that the race will go on. Where will people stay? How will they get there? Half of NYC is still without power. The Mayor may say that it should be back on by Sunday, but there are no guarantees. After the derecho storm this summer, power was out for over a week, and there was no flooding – just downed power lines and blown transformers.
    While I get the idea that having the race go on could help with morale, I wonder how widespread that really will be? Even on a lovely day, people resent having their neighborhoods taken over by a race. How will they feel seeing so many public resources going to support a race while they are sifting through their damaged homes?

    Tonight the mayor of Hoboken was on the news pleading for water and food and supplies. Wouldn’t it be better if whatever water and food was heading for the marathon was donated to storm victims?

    If I were signed up and could get there, I might want the race to go on. If I was not a runner, I’m not sure I would feel so generous.

    As to Charlotte’s comment, by not cancelling, do they get to keep all entry fees? Are people allowed to defer?

    Like

  11. Jess Avatar
    Jess

    I am on the fence regarding whether or not the race should go on. But from the beginning they’ve only reported that it will. I haven’t heard once otherwise.
    And yes, I do think there are big questions about whether or not we need to pull police officers and medics away from those who might need them. But we also need to remember that those officers and medics are being compensated by NYRR. They aren’t using public funds that would otherwise go to the victims of the hurricaine or anyone else. But they are taking time away from them. And I think a big concern is how they can logistically run a race through areas that are so devastated. How are they even going to start in Staten Island?

    That being said, I was at the race after 9/11. I understand that this is a different situation completely. And it was not so soon after. But I have never seen a city pull together more than I did that year. And I have never seen or experienced a race more meaningful than that one. So for that reason, I do understand why they want to proceed.

    Like

  12. Saturday Stories | The Courage of Lungs Avatar

    […] With all of the debate surrounding whether the New York Marathon should have been cancelled here is a good post on crisis communications and how the NYRR handled the situation.  […]

    Like

  13. steena Avatar

    From day 1 of the hurricane/super storm I thought they should cancel it… I kept my twitter-mouth shut because I’ve learned that arguing opinions on the internet leads to craziness.

    Like

    1. David H. Avatar

      This time around, I think the arguments were worth it. Many people didn’t understand the situation, nor do they now. It’s a conversation that needs to keep going.

      Like

Leave a comment